Well, first off im no-one to say if you failed or not. That is something you must come to terms with. I will say this...some of the most fit blokes don't get in, while some of the weakest do! the Legion needs more than just super strong guys, they need some who are very intelligent, those who speak a couple of languages, those who can run or play music. Every selection is different, different people are chosen or sent home. In my selection i got sick, swollen tonsils and all, i was put in the infirmerie for a week till i healed up then i was put with the next batch of rouge. Some others who went to the infirmerie were not so lucky. I have said it once and i will say it a million times over, it is a popularity contest. Let me explain...There is a board of about 5-7 Legionnaires who after two weeks or so go over a list of possibles for Castel... If you did not pass the run for example that's one guy who will say your not fit, so he votes against you, then if you don't pass medical for something like weight, the doctor will say no also, but if the bureau de security (gestapo-for us older Legionnaires) says yes as with a couple of CCHs or SGTs in "CAPLE" plus you might have a skill or trade they are looking for, weel they are out voted so you get to go to Castel, once a total of 50 are chosen then the rest are sent home and told to try again in 60 or 90 days. That's just how it is. I know of an Italian who was wanted by Interpol, which is a big no-no, but because he spoke three languages and played 5 musical instuments he was allowed to join, not only that but he was passed through instruction, meaning he should have failed but the Music Principal needed him so he was given his kepi and after instruction sent to Aubagne. Whew, i've written alot. There you go. As for whether or not someone is or is not a legionnaire... i can only say this: If all they seem to talk about is Selection or Castel but never say anything about Regiment then i would not believe them to be legionnaires. If their entire experience is limited to Aubagne or Castel... they are not legionnaires. I don't know too many legionnaires who down right hate the Legion, in fact i don't know any. Also as to address hitting....when i was in YES you got pounded! Discipline is achieved through various methods!!! Now though it's not as bad as it used to be, but it will still happen, if you're a "mongol" (idiot), or just plain ugly!
Mle 187-828